Asphalt vs. Tar & Chip: Which Is Right for You?
Choosing a driveway surface is one of the biggest decisions homeowners in the Eastern Panhandle face. Whether you live in Martinsburg, Charles Town, or Shepherdstown, the two most popular options are hot-mix asphalt and tar & chip (also called chip seal). Here's how they compare:
Hot-Mix Asphalt
Asphalt is the most popular driveway surface in Berkeley County and throughout West Virginia for good reason:
- Smooth, uniform finish — ideal for a polished, modern look
- Excellent for high-traffic driveways and parking lots — handles heavy vehicles without rutting
- Easy to sealcoat for long-term maintenance — a fresh sealcoat every 2-3 years keeps it looking new
- Typically lasts 15-20 years with proper care and regular maintenance
Asphalt is the go-to choice for homeowners in Martinsburg, Shepherdstown, and Ranson who want a clean, professional appearance and don't mind periodic sealcoating.
Tar & Chip
Tar & chip is a popular alternative, especially among rural property owners near Gerrardstown, Berkeley Springs, and Hedgesville:
- Textured, rustic appearance that blends naturally with rural and wooded settings
- Lower upfront cost than hot-mix asphalt — often 30-40% less
- Good traction — the stone chips provide grip, making it less slippery in wet or icy conditions
- No sealcoating required — though a fresh chip layer may be needed over time
Tar & chip is especially popular on longer driveways throughout Morgan County and the rural areas of Jefferson County, where the natural look complements the landscape.
Which Should You Choose?
If you want a sleek, modern look and plan to maintain it with regular sealcoating, asphalt is the way to go. If you prefer a natural look, have a longer rural driveway, or want to save on upfront costs, tar & chip is an excellent choice.
Either way, A+ Paving & Landscaping installs both surfaces across West Virginia and Pennsylvania. Request a free estimate and we'll walk through the options on-site to help you make the best decision for your property.